super junior? i hate them. - ☞ icon critique meme
my name is aiden lee
donghae
..::: ..:..:. . :::: ::::.
May 2020
          1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31

looking at you... only you

you, I can't forget you

my name is aiden lee [userpic]
☞ icon critique meme

ICONCRITMEME

<
♠ reply to this post with your username and/or journal you post your icons at. along with that, post 5-12 icon samples, so everyone can give you some of their thoughts too.

♡ reply to people's ( even people that you aren't familiar with an outsider's perspective is good ) comments with critiques and opinions on their icons. anonymous comments are enabled and ip logging is disabled, if you feel you need to use that option.

♣ try to be polite, but at the same time honest. the purpose of this meme is to be helpful, so any wank will be deleted.

♢ pimp this out in your journal and/or icon community, etcetera.

Comments
(Anonymous) - (no subject)

A WILD OWL APPEARED +_+

WAS NOT EXPECTING IN-DEPTH CRITIQUE. But thanks for taking the time to really write out what you thought. D: It means a lot and I'll be taking a second look at some of my manga coloring for things you pointed out. ♥

also what are you doing awake young lady

(Anonymous) - (no subject)

FFFFF I WOULDN'T WORRY ABOUT IT. I'd rather have a few long, thought out replies than a shitton of short ones that don't really offer much insight.

Oh.

Well.

):

ALSO LMFAO THAT ICON. I've been trying to figure out the best way to icon that image and someone else did it for me. FUCK YEAR

(Anonymous) - (no subject)

ALWAYS IN HANDY!

I PROBABLY WILL. Deathscythe is the best papa out there ;;

(Anonymous) - (no subject)



haha I wish I could play him somewhere. *^* But afjdkf yeah I got into it because of Kid THANKS A LOT ASHFACE. >:

I GOT NOTHIN' much to say, really, other than a couple small gripes.

#s 8, 11, and 12 all have that oversaturated/almost-too-bright color scheme that bothers me, like the bright yellow hair/overpowering red that really steals the show for the rest of the icon, and #11 looks a tad oversharpened.

THAT ASIDE THOUGH I really love the subtle blending on 1, 2, and 9. The Duo icon especially, I love to see more subdued hues balanced really well on a dark icon.

...OH AND PUT MORE SHADING/HIGHLIGHTS IN HAIR GDIT I don't know orz;

/IS SO VERY HELPFUL!?! I love your icons daughter. >:

PAPA GIVES CRITIQUE TOO WHY ARE YOU PEOPLE EVEN AWAKE AT THIS HOUR fjasdklfrijoles

AS FOR... THOSE. idk, a lot of it was just messing around with different effects and ish, but I'll definitely take it into account when I start coloring manga scans again.

AND THANK YOU.

THE SHADING/HIGHLIGHTS NEVER LAST LONG WITH MY COLORING sob.

PAPA IS SO VERY HELPFUL >:

LOL BECAUSE.... IT WAS RAINING AND I SLEPT UNTIL 2:30 IN THE AFTERNOON. SO I AM STILL AWAKE.

Doesn't daughter have a tablet too? >: >:

LOL WHY NOT.

Papa... will agree to disagree. :| /puntnuzzle

OH. WELL. That's a good reason to sleep. >:

Yes, daughter only has a tablet and no mouse. >:

BECAUSE THEN I ADD A FILL LAYER and it disappeeeeaaaars that and I don't really make it stand out that much. /lol realism

...HOW DO I GET PUNTED AND NUZZLED AT THE SAME TIME? D8

Awww yeah I don't have a mouse either sob. Though my tablet has one, and I TECHNICALLY have a mouse but I never use either in this setup.

LOL FILL LAYER WHY WOULD YOU EVER. Just color with screen & multiply LIKE A NORMAL PERSON GOD DAMN.

Haha mine are subtle to as seen here in this icon. ):

BECAUSE PAPAS ARE ALLOWED TO DO THAT. >O

aha I don't even have the mouse for my tablet. ;; Left it at my mother's when I moved.

BECAUSE IT BRINGS OUT OTHER COLORS. And I do use a linear burn layer. >( AND AUGH I HATE SCREEN LAYERS WITH A FIERY PASSION. fjlksdjf

Yeah but it's sexy so it's okay.

PAPA WHYYYYY

WHY YOU HATE ON SCREEN LAYERS, THEY DO BEAUTIFUL THINGS. HAVE YOU SEEN MY MANGA ICONS?! HAVE YOU!? WIPOERNHWEPORJWPERK

/says this like her icons are actually good hahaha


BECAUSE WE DEFY ALL LOGICS OF THE WORLD.

(Anonymous) - (no subject)

I have kind of an ungodly love for that girl, no joke. ;_; I'M GLAD SOMEONE KNOWS HER. ♥