I love how you're not scared to try crazy things with your icons! Lovelovelove it. Also, your black and white stuff is some of the best I've ever seen. Especially that b&w Basch icon you have posted right there.

I think that your strongest point is your text though. You're really good at placement and variety with text. :3

Sometimes your coloring is a bit off, imo. I think it has to do with textures. Like in the Auron icon. I think it would've looked better if it was completely b&w.

*hides in a hole* I don't like critiquing. Can you tell? XD

edit: edited for excessive use of the word "though". *smacks forehead*